"The reason for my answer is the continuation of the "legend" that Commanche was the only survivor of the battle. I believe he was just lucky. He probably ran off during the fight and returned after.   I also believe there were…"

"There is a photo with Commanche and a smaller gray horse that was taken after the battle but there is no documentation on why or where the grey horse came from..just makes one think that there was a reason for the grey being in the photo with…"

"Of course, Stan. "

"I would think there were a lot of horses captured by the indians. Both the Cheyenne and the Sioux valued horses too much to just kill them.   I think the idea that they killed all the horses was just added to the story to further incite the…"

"The gray horse was named Nap."

"It is for sure that Commanche was not gray.  The son of Chief Lame Deer brought north a gray gelding that was about 12 years old.  This was in 1877.  Colonel Irvine visited the camp where the boy and horse were.  He saw, and…"

"Never heard of em' neither. But I did hear tell of a Walker who fought, and died, back during the Mexican War. That was Samuel Walker a Texas Ranger who helped design a hefty Colts six shooter that became known as "The Walker Colt'.…"

"Never heard of either one.  Besides the famous outlaws, i know the wild bunch was a loose gang.  About how many were in the gang"